With The Disappearance of Eleanor Rigby, writer-director Ned Benson has made a romance that says that while love may not last forever, at least you can extend it by playing through as multiple characters. The film--films, actually--tells a love story, marred by tragedy, in three different ways. There's the "Him" version, the "Her" version, and the "Them" version--the guest towel for we the collective outsider. That take hits theaters first on September 26, with the personalized spins arriving six weeks later. Then you can decide if you're on James McAvoy's side or Jessica Chastain's side, just in time to know who to invite for Thanksgiving.